Contact Us
This form does not yet contain any fields.
    Search Wo40
    Recent Site Activity

    Measuring Fat-Loss Progress

    There it sits.  Mocking.  Foreboding.  Daring me to step on and check on my "progress".

    Some years ago, however, I discovered that the scale is really a poor indicator of progress when it comes to losing weight.  There are a million variables that come into play when it comes to physical weight that make any significant day-by-day information all but impossible to obtain.  Certainly I can step on the scale right now (something I actually did before sitting down to write this), but what am I going to learn.  According to the scale I weigh 199.5 right now.  Since my scale saves my current weight against my previous weight, I have learned that I gained 2.5 pounds in the last few days.


    You mean all of those decisions to drink water and not soda, eat greens and lean meats instead of fast food - those decisions actually gained me 2.5 pounds?  I'm actually going backwards?  Screw that!  I'm quitting now!

    Well, maybe not.  Let's analyze the facts here.  The last time I weighed in there were a couple of things that were different.  For instance, when I weighed myself a few days ago I was wearing nothing but my skivvies.  Tonight I had on pants, and socks (in addition to my knickers).  That in itself might be good for a half pound or so.  So what about the other 2 pounds?  Well, the last time I weighed myself, I did it first thing in the morning after a shower.  After an 8-hour fast, my stomach was empty.  The same cannot be said of my weigh-in a few minutes ago, since I've been eating my (clean) meals and drinking water all day.  All of that intake hasn't been consumed by my body, so I weigh more now than I did a few days ago.  If I weigh myself tomorrow morning (which I will do for comparison sake), chances are the 2.5 pounds will have gone their way (in addition to a little more weight).


    As I get further into this weight loss adventure, other variables will come into play.  For example, in time I will appear to stop losing weight as I begin developing lean muscle mass while losing fat.  The scale will tell me that I am losing marginal amounts of weight, making me want to tighten my diet even more.  That would be counter-productive if the actual process is one of muscle gain and fat loss occurring at the same time.  Another example - once a low body fat percentage has been achieved, I could actually gain weight from month to month as I develop muscle mass without losing much fat.  If I use the scale as the sole determiner of progress, I will be nothing more than frustrated by my "lack" of progress.

    In order to gauge progress, I will draw from a number of different pieces of information.  A good starting point is the change in the way I feel.  While this is not the best indicator of progress at first (mainly because my body feels a little sluggish due to caffeine withdrawal and the significant reduction in caloric intake), it will become a very good indicator of progress as my body grows in strength.

    Another good progress test can be the clothing test.  Do my clothes fit better?  Are they loose compared to a week or two ago?  Does a 36" waist pant feel better than a 38" waist pair?  Can I actually wear the pair of pants I bought a year ago but never wore because my butt was too fat?  Does my belt need to be tightened to 4 holes instead of just 3?  These are definite, tangible indicators of progress.

    One of my all-time favorite measures of progress is the third-party assessment.  This check of progress occurs whenever you see someone after a month or two of working out and their first comment after greeting you is, "have you lost weight?"  Oh, yeah.  That's the feeling.  Right there.

    There are higher-tech methods of measuring progress - body fat percentage via caliper measurements or hydrostatic immersion - but nothing hits home like fitting into your high school drum major uniform or having someone look at you with a bit of a squint as they say, "you look different."


    Be well.

    ** Update - I weighed in this morning at 195.5, 4 pounds lighter than I weighed last night.  The only change between then an now is 8 hours of sleep and a couple trips to the bathroom.  I plan on sticking to a once-a-week plan for weighing myself.  I'll weigh in on Monday mornings, keeping the crazy day-to-day fluctuations from causing frustration.

    References (1)

    References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

    Reader Comments

    There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

    PostPost a New Comment

    Enter your information below to add a new comment.

    My response is on my own website »
    Author Email (optional):
    Author URL (optional):
    Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>